News

How to Order as a Holiday Gift 🎁

Planning to give a Mail Order Mystery as a holiday gift? We have three words for you: DO NOT WAIT.

Every mystery is personalized and packed with care, and we only have so many hands. We won’t take more orders than we can personalize and ship, so if we hit our limit we’ll have to put up the “sold out” sign until we catch up. In past years, some mysteries have sold out as Christmas got closer.

First, pick a mystery. All of our mysteries are great for girls and boys. Younger kids (6-7 years old) do best with a grown-up, sibling or friend as a sidekick, and Escape the Master Loop is perfect for a group that includes adults and teens. Not sure which one fits? Our handy guide will help you choose by age.


Next, choose how it’s delivered. When you pick your mystery you’ll see two options: everything shipped in one box, or six installments sent weekly.

ALL-IN-ONE BOX: best when you need it in hand by a certain date. We ship it as soon as we can, usually within 7 days, and you’ll get tracking information. That means you can stash an awesome gift in the closet, ready to wrap. You choose the name on the shipping label (so kids don’t know it’s for them), and the letters inside are personalized to the kid(s) receiving the mystery. The envelopes are numbered on the back, so you can hand out each installment at your own pace. You get exactly the same mystery and personalization as if you get the letter mailed weekly, but you don't have to worry about mail delays.

SEND WEEKLY: best for kids who love getting mail. You choose the date we mail the first letter, then we mail one every Tuesday for six weeks. Letter mail has no tracking, and we can’t control how fast the post office delivers it, so this option isn’t ideal if something has to arrive on a specific day.

Giving Send Weekly as a holiday gift? We suggest wrapping the printable gift note and planning for the mystery to start arriving shortly after Christmas or in the new year. Mail is unpredictable at the best of times, and even more so in December.

Picking a start date for Send Weekly? These are our best estimates, not guarantees:

Order by Dec 3: first letter mails Dec 8, likely arrives before Christmas
Order by Dec 10: first letter mails Dec 15, likely arrives just before or just after Christmas
Order by Dec 17: first letter mails Dec 22, likely arrives early in the new year

All-In-One Box order-by dates are on our holiday shipping dates page.

OK, we know that’s a lot of information! Questions? Email us at info@mailordermystery.com. We hope we can help you add the joy and subtract the stress this holiday season!