Highest rated

The Case of the Missing Bigfoot

Ages 9+ · Detective

A whodunnit set in an old mansion not far from where they live. When a safe at the mansion is emptied, the detectives call in a keen young sleuth to help crack the case.

$119.00
How should it arrive?

Same mystery either way, with every envelope addressed to your kid by name. Compare the two

Delivery Option
  • All-In-One Box: usually arrives 9 to 15 days after you order, with tracking.
  • One-time purchase, never a subscription
  • Personalized with your kid's name (you'll add it in the next step)
  • Lost letters replaced free

This is such a well put together, smart, engaging and fun mystery! My 8 year old loved this and it was a great activity for us to do together.

- Sarah D.

Ages 9 and up. Great for girls and boys. The Case of the Missing Bigfoot is certified “not scary” (but extremely cool) by our Very Nervous Story Tester.

Not sure it’s the right fit? Compare all five mysteries →

An old mansion. A dinner party about to begin. The lights go out, there’s an upset in the dining room, an upset in the upstairs hall. The lights come on, the safe is open and the contents are gone. Who did it? The detectives on the scene need the help of a keen and curious young sleuth to help them solve the case.


And by the way, the mansion is not far from where you live. A big hairy creature that may or may not be Bigfoot was recently spotted in the area. You haven’t seen anything out of the ordinary, have you?


What am I getting when I order The Case of the Missing Bigfoot?

The Case of the Missing Bigfoot is a one-time purchase, never a subscription: five envelopes and a final package, mailed weekly or all together in the All-In-One Box. The envelopes from the detectives on the scene contain all sorts of evidence, objects and clues, including “crime scene” photos, fingerprint reports, interview transcripts, ciphers and a suspect board to help keep track of the case. The final package contains a super cool cryptid hunting field kit, including a set of collector cards, a notebook and a canvas bag.

Can I see what I get when I order The Case of the Missing Bigfoot?

For a detailed look at what you'll get in each mailing, see our Tell me more about The Case of the Missing Bigfoot page.

Warning: The surprise could be compromised.

Is The Case of the Missing Bigfoot the right choice for me?

The Case of the Missing Bigfoot is a detective-style whodunnit and our highest-rated mystery. We recommend it for ages 9 and up because it's substantial and elaborate, with quite a bit of reading, which makes it a great pick for kids who love to read. Kids 7 and 8 who love Bigfoot, mysterious creatures or detective stories often do great reading it with an adult, and it's a hit with 11- and 12-year-olds who love a good whodunnit.

For kids who are into Bigfoot, the Yeti and the Loch Ness Monster, there's a lot to discover about cryptozoology beyond the monster-hunting craze. And the canvas field bag in the final installment is SO COOL that almost everyone on the Mail Order Mystery team has claimed one for their own.

Still deciding? Our Help Me Choose guide compares all five mysteries by age, reading and challenge, with advice from 4,800+ reviews.

Help! I am stuck solving this mystery.

If you are playing through The Case of the Missing Bigfoot and you need help with a puzzle or clue, we have a parent guide.

This guide contains hints for every puzzle and activity, and a separate section for answers so you don’t see spoilers unless you want to. There are ongoing summaries to help you catch up on the story.

You can also use this guide to put the mystery back in order if it gets mixed up and check to see if anything is missing. Good luck, detective!

Mail Order Mysteries are not for children under three. Small parts could present a choking hazard.

Customer Reviews

Based on 656 reviews
82%
(536)
9%
(60)
5%
(32)
3%
(17)
2%
(11)
S
Sara Cremeans
So fun!!

My 11 year old was so excited to check the mail every day! This was way better than I expected. We had fun solving the different codes together. I will definitely be ordering another one. The clues were so well done! I couldn’t believe the suspect board and the photographs! Amazing. Way exceeded my expectations.

J
Julie Benns
The Case of the Missing Bigfoot

My 9 year old granddaughter loved it way more than I could have imagined. She diligently worked away at it on a daily basis, the whole family was involved, looking forward to each new delivery that finally led to solving the case! Much loved!

J
Josh Klemmer
Amazing experience for the whole family

My stepdaughter has never been more excited to check the mail, and spend time with mom and me discussing who may have stolen the Bigfoot photos. I am ordering the next round, she will be over the moon. Thank you for giving us such a fun thing to do together.

M
Merrie Hultman
Case of the missing big foot

I got this for my 10 year old niece for Christmas. My whole family got into this mystery and enjoyed every time a new part came in the mail!! Even a few friends got into solving it. They said they couldn’t sleep until it was solved!They couldn’t wait for the mail to come. Now my niece wants me to order more. Maybe I will do that for her birthday!

D
Darcy L.
Perfect Gift For a Puzzle-Loving Kid!

My 10 year-old daughter has loved the mystery experience. We're halfway through the mailings now. She continues to think and talk about the clues throughout the day even when she doesn't have them out in front of her. The ciphers are pretty challenging, and we don't see how all of the pieces fit into place just yet. But, since she knows that she'll get a hint each week, it's not overwhelming or frustrating for her. I definitely will buy more from Mail Order Mysteries in the future.