Choose your mystery

Five personalized mysteries for ages 6 to 12+, each one mailed to your kid by the characters in the story. First mystery? Treasure Hunt! is our best seller and a great place to start.

Not sure which one? Compare them by age, reading and challenge →

As featured in The New York Times Wirecutter, 2026
★★★★★
4.6 / 5 from 4,800+ reviews
Loved by 200,000+ families

Best seller

Treasure Hunt!

Ages 6+ · Pirates

From $109

Long-lost treasure, double-crossing pirates and a pirate ancestor from their own family. It ends with a wooden treasure chest.

Send this mystery

The Enchanted Slumber

Ages 6+ · Fairy tale

From $114

A knight, a troll, a librarian and a dragon need their help to wake a princess who has been asleep for almost 700 years.

Send this mystery

For code crackers

Spies, Lies and Serious Bad Guys!

Ages 9+ · Spies

From $119

It starts with an acceptance letter to spy school. Then comes the mission: find a missing agent and stop a villain.

Send this mystery

Highest rated

The Case of the Missing Bigfoot

Ages 9+ · Detective

From $119

A safe has been emptied at an old mansion not far from where they live, and something big and hairy was spotted nearby.

Send this mystery

Great for groups

Escape the Master Loop

Ages 12+, or 9+ with grown-up help · Time travel

From $114

Urgent letters from their future self about the mess they've made of the time travel universe. Perfect for family game night.

Send this mystery

Still deciding?

Our guide compares all five mysteries by age, reading and challenge, with advice from 4,800+ reviews.

Help me choose a mystery

Two ways to send it

Same mystery either way, with the same personalization and every envelope addressed to them by name.

Our pick

All-In-One Box

All six installments arrive together in one tracked box. Inside, every envelope still has their name and address on it, so you can slip each letter into the mailbox when it's time.

  • Usually arrives 9 to 15 days after you order
  • Tracked, with express shipping available
  • No worrying about mail delays or letters arriving out of order
  • Best for gifts with a date and faraway grandparents

Send Weekly

One letter mailed each week for six weeks, so they get the thrill of mail with their name on it, week after week.

  • You pick the date the first letter is mailed
  • The first letter usually arrives 5 to 10 business days later
  • Letter mail, so there's no tracking and delivery timing can vary. Letters are numbered on the back in case they arrive out of order.
  • Best for building anticipation, one mailbox moment at a time

Compare delivery options →

Good to know

One-time purchase

Never a subscription. You pay once for all six installments, right up to the keepsake at the end.

Printable gift note

Giving it as a gift? You can download a printable gift note, so there's something to hand over on the day, even if the mystery starts later.

Lost something? We'll replace it

Letter mail can be slow, so give each letter a little extra time. If one goes missing, we'll send a new one free, no questions asked. Same goes for a lost clue, even if the dog ate it.

What our customers think

★★★★★

Exceeded high expectations!

9 and 11 year old siblings declared this the best gift ever! Encouraged collaborative, analog problem-solving… really high quality and worth the price.

- Karen I.

★★★★★

Pirate Treasure Mystery

Bought this for my 8 year old grandson. He loved it and looked forward to the coded letters each week. When the treasure chest finally came, he thought it was awesome and wanted to take it to school for show and tell.

- Debbie N.

★★★★★

Tons of fun

I bought this for my niece who loves mysteries. She called me to thank me for the gift and told me how much fun she had solving the mystery.

- Krista L.

★★★★★

My granddaughter said she would give it 300 on 5!

What a fun experience instead of just gifting them a toy. There was the sense of accomplishment as well as many little treasures along the way!

- Crystal E.

★★★★★

11 year old is highly engaged!

I bought this for my grand nephew's 11th birthday. He's a bright, thoughtful, creative boy who loves to read. His mom sent photos of him working very seriously, with his highlighter in hand, and studying the clues. It's a very satisfying gift in so many ways. I'm so pleased!

- Meredith T.

★★★★★

A huge hit with the Grandkids

I bought this for my grandson for Christmas and was his best gift ever. Also allowed me to spend quality time having a blast, being challenged and testing our skills all at the same time. I would definitely buy again and highly recommend you do it together!

- Carolyn D.

Read all 4,800+ reviews →

Choose your mystery